Previous Entry | Next Entry

Bones and Nerds


Normally, I like the TV show "Bones," a forensic anthropology show with David Boreanez actually acting instead of just standing around and moping.

I like the subject matter a lot, I like the characters, the writing is pretty sharp, and it's an interesting show.

Yesterday's episode, though, I didn't like as much.

See, there's this kid who was home schooled. And he was a loser, big time. He spent all of his time in his oddly clean, oddly huge, bedroom reading comic books and collecting toys. According to his parents, he had no friends at all, and just lived in a fantasy world, and this totally didn't bother them or make them thing of maybe getting him some psychological help. He was found dead, dressed in a super hero outfit. It turns out that he hung out with a bunch of other social rejects who like to dress up in super hero outfits and listen to crappy music really really loudly in the attic of their local comic book shop.

The main character, Dr. Temperance "Bones" Brennan, and Boreanz's character (whose name I totally forget, God help me), bust their way up into their private meeting, without identifying themselves as being from the FBI. When the youth in costumes object to their presence, Boreanez's character points out that OMG there's a woman with him!!! And they never see women!!! So they should pay attention and mind their manners zomg wtf lolz!!! Despite the fact that there was a woman right fucking there with them. The hell?

It's quickly settled that among the main characters in the show, none of them read omg comic books except for Boreanez, who only reads superman and objects to being called a nerd, because all red blooded American males apparently both read Superman and know what individual old issues are worth. The little nerdly guy with the super high IQ, despite being huge into Sci Fi, has never read comics. So he reads some, and stresses how "comic books and graphic novels" are basicly just retelling old hero myths. Which is like saying that both short stories and books are something or other.

The whole show left me with a really bad taste in my mouth. It felt like an attack on anyone who reads comic books... or if not an out and out attack, then a continuation that people who read comics aren't really humans and therefore it's ok to make fun of them because they're just a bunch of little nerds who can't hack the real world. The victim's parents were so uninvolved in his life that it felt almost abusive, but nobody called them on it or questioned their behavior towards him. It just felt... wrong. Off key.

Eh. Maybe I'm over sensitive. But the writing just felt lazy, like nobody could be bothered to do any research into comics culture behind 50 year old stereotypes. Even the art of the victim's comic was dated-- printed on glossy paper (did they use Lulu or something to self-publish?) and very mid-90s.

Comments

( 10 comments — Leave a comment )
[info]idemandjustice wrote:
Feb. 9th, 2006 04:39 pm (UTC)
I wish they hadn't moved the show to the same time slot as LOST. I don't have a way to record a show while watching another because our cable sucks. So I don't get to watch Bones anymore.
[info]shadefell wrote:
Feb. 9th, 2006 05:30 pm (UTC)
I've managed to neatly avoid that problem by never watching LOST!

Actually, I'm pissed that they moved House and Bones to different days. Now I watch TV twice a week instead of once. >:(

If you have high speed internet access and are willing to download shows from the internet, you should be able to download missed episodes of Bones or any other tv show. For awhile, some television station was offering that as a feature... you got the commercials, also.

[info]serrana wrote:
Feb. 9th, 2006 05:54 pm (UTC)
We watched the first few of these and I decided it was just too gory for me. I really can't watch shows where little kids die in terrible ways. Also, frankly, I used to work down the hall from South Carolina's bone lab, and it was nothing like the show...and C. doesn't think much of it when I yell at the TV about anthropological inaccuracies.

You could always tell when someone had died, because the whole building smelled like corpses. Especially in the winter.
[info]shadefell wrote:
Feb. 9th, 2006 06:18 pm (UTC)
Yea, I have a hobby interest in forensic anthrophology (I thought about studying it for awhile) and I can often tell when they fudge stuff or make it up entirely. Their magical digital imaging thing that operates on Hollywood OS? I hate that. But the rest of the show is enjoyable enough. I don't mind the gore so much.

I currently work a few blocks from the county morgue, which is a low white building with a steeply sloping blue roof. It looks like an IHOP, oddly enough. Every time my fiance drives past it, he refers to it as IHOC... International House of Corpses.
[info]eveanhei wrote:
Feb. 9th, 2006 09:54 pm (UTC)
Sounds more ridiculous to me, to be honest.
[info]shadefell wrote:
Feb. 9th, 2006 10:16 pm (UTC)
It was really derogatory. Like, every time some mentioned comic books who wasn't in to them, they had this kind of sneer. Like... "Oh... comic books. I'm surprised you don't read them, nerdly side kick. I mean, you're into STAR wars, STAR trek, STAR gate, battle STAR galactica. You're so nerdly I'm surprised you can remember to breathe without a prompt! Nerd nerd nerd."

It was pretty ridiculous. But in a mean spirited way.

Here. Let me lay it on the line. Reading comic books does not usually cause a teen ager to dress up in a crime fighting outfit and stab someone with a beveled chisel used for cleaning out bowling balls. There's really no correlation between the two, outside of this show.
[info]eveanhei wrote:
Feb. 10th, 2006 10:54 pm (UTC)
Now, I have to agree to that.
[info]goblinator wrote:
Feb. 9th, 2006 10:38 pm (UTC)
I missed it last night because I had to go to a lecture seminar. What you described is pretty funny considering one of the show's premises is how out of touch with modern society Temperance and the geeky assistant are.

I agree that the show is sharply written, but the characters do get a bit stereotypical (the out-of-touch scientist, the socially awkward grad student, the fun loving artist, the Stephen Hyde ripoff conspiracy theorist, the stoic African.) Boreanaz has the only character that doesn't annoy me in that way.
[info]shadefell wrote:
Feb. 10th, 2006 12:54 am (UTC)
Oh, yea, they're cliches... but they are self aware cliches, and that makes them far more tolerable. I also get the feeling that some of the characters are in-jokes based either on the books or else on the reality the books are based on.

I keep meaning to pick up the books the show is based on, but can never remember the real author's name because I'm developing some pretty serious memory problems.
(Anonymous) wrote:
Mar. 30th, 2006 09:13 pm (UTC)
Kathy Reich.
And you're in for a shock - the books aren't anything like the show except for the name of the main character.

Thanks for the show description though - you came top of my google search for this episode.

Jax
(http://liveotherwise.co.uk/makingitup/ - don't have an openid I'm afraid)
( 10 comments — Leave a comment )

Latest Month

February 2012
S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829   

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Teresa Jones